CaltechAUTHORS
Published July 10, 2023 | Version Published
Journal Article Open

The NANOGrav 15 yr Data Set: Bayesian Limits on Gravitational Waves from Individual Supermassive Black Hole Binaries

Creators

  • 1. ROR icon University of Wisconsin–Milwaukee
  • 2. ROR icon Newcastle University
  • 3. ROR icon Goddard Space Flight Center
  • 4. ROR icon Widener University
  • 5. ROR icon Oregon State University
  • 6. ROR icon University of Florida
  • 7. ROR icon Cornell University
  • 8. ROR icon University of Birmingham
  • 9. ROR icon West Virginia University
  • 10. ROR icon University of Connecticut
  • 11. ROR icon Vanderbilt University
  • 12. ROR icon New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology
  • 13. ROR icon Montana State University
  • 14. ROR icon Franklin & Marshall College
  • 15. ROR icon University of British Columbia
  • 16. ROR icon United States Naval Research Laboratory
  • 17. ROR icon National Radio Astronomy Observatory
  • 18. ROR icon Hillsdale College
  • 19. ROR icon Eureka Scientific
  • 20. ROR icon Rochester Institute of Technology
  • 21. ROR icon University of Maryland, College Park
  • 22. ROR icon University of Michigan–Ann Arbor
  • 23. ROR icon California Institute of Technology
  • 24. ROR icon University of California, Berkeley
  • 25. ROR icon Jet Propulsion Lab
  • 26. ROR icon State University of New York at Oswego
  • 27. ROR icon University of Toronto
  • 28. ROR icon University of the Pacific
  • 29. ROR icon University of Hull
  • 30. ROR icon International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research
  • 31. ROR icon Yale University
  • 32. ROR icon Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron DESY
  • 33. ROR icon Lafayette College
  • 34. ROR icon Tufts University
  • 35. ROR icon Eötvös Loránd University
  • 36. ROR icon Arecibo Observatory
  • 37. ROR icon University of Puerto Rico System
  • 38. ROR icon Texas Tech University
  • 39. ROR icon Pennsylvania State University
  • 40. ROR icon University of Münster
  • 41. ROR icon University of Colorado Boulder
  • 42. ROR icon Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics
  • 43. ROR icon Oberlin College
  • 44. ROR icon Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
  • 45. ROR icon Feza Gürsey Institute
  • 46. ROR icon Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics
  • 47. ROR icon Northwestern University
  • 48. ROR icon Adler Planetarium

Abstract

Evidence for a low-frequency stochastic gravitational-wave background has recently been reported based on analyses of pulsar timing array data. The most likely source of such a background is a population of supermassive black hole binaries, the loudest of which may be individually detected in these data sets. Here we present the search for individual supermassive black hole binaries in the NANOGrav 15 yr data set. We introduce several new techniques, which enhance the efficiency and modeling accuracy of the analysis. The search uncovered weak evidence for two candidate signals, one with a gravitational-wave frequency of ∼4 nHz, and another at ∼170 nHz. The significance of the low-frequency candidate was greatly diminished when Hellings–Downs correlations were included in the background model. The high-frequency candidate was discounted due to the lack of a plausible host galaxy, the unlikely astrophysical prior odds of finding such a source, and since most of its support comes from a single pulsar with a commensurate binary period. Finding no compelling evidence for signals from individual binary systems, we place upper limits on the strain amplitude of gravitational waves emitted by such systems. At our most sensitive frequency of 6 nHz, we place a sky-averaged 95% upper limit of 8 × 10−15 on the strain amplitude. We also calculate an exclusion volume and a corresponding effective radius, within which we can rule out the presence of black hole binaries emitting at a given frequency.

Copyright and License

© 2023. The Author(s). Published by the American Astronomical Society. Original content from this work may be used under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 licence. Any further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the title of the work, journal citation and DOI.

Acknowledgement

The NANOGrav collaboration receives support from National Science Foundation (NSF) Physics Frontiers Center award Nos. 1430284 and 2020265, the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation, NSF AccelNet award No. 2114721, an NSERC Discovery Grant, and CIFAR. The Arecibo Observatory is a facility of the NSF operated under cooperative agreement (AST-1744119) by the University of Central Florida (UCF) in alliance with Universidad Ana G. Méndez (UAGM) and Yang Enterprises (YEI), Inc. The Green Bank Observatory is a facility of the NSF operated under cooperative agreement by Associated Universities, Inc. The National Radio Astronomy Observatory is a facility of the NSF operated under cooperative agreement by Associated Universities, Inc. L.B. acknowledges support from the National Science Foundation under award AST-1909933 and from the Research Corporation for Science Advancement under Cottrell Scholar Award No. 27553. P.R.B. is supported by the Science and Technology Facilities Council, grant No. ST/W000946/1. S.B. gratefully acknowledges the support of a Sloan Fellowship, and the support of NSF under award No. 1815664. The work of R.C., N.La., X.S., and J.T. is partly supported by the George and Hannah Bolinger Memorial Fund in the College of Science at Oregon State University. M.C., P.P., and S.R.T. acknowledge support from NSF AST-2007993. M.C. and N.S.P. were supported by the Vanderbilt Initiative in Data Intensive Astrophysics (VIDA) Fellowship. Support for this work was provided by the NSF through the Grote Reber Fellowship Program administered by Associated Universities, Inc./National Radio Astronomy Observatory. Support for H.T.C. is provided by NASA through the NASA Hubble Fellowship Program grant No. HST-HF2-51453.001 awarded by the Space Telescope Science Institute, which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., for NASA, under contract NAS5-26555. K.C. is supported by a UBC Four Year Fellowship (6456). M.E.D. acknowledges support from the Naval Research Laboratory by NASA under contract S-15633Y. T.D. and M.T.L. are supported by an NSF Astronomy and Astrophysics Grant (AAG) award No. 2009468. E.C.F. is supported by NASA under award No. 80GSFC21M0002. G.E.F., S.C.S., and S.J.V. are supported by NSF award PHY-2011772. The Flatiron Institute is supported by the Simons Foundation. S.H. is supported by the National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship under grant No. DGE-1745301. A.D.J. and M.V. acknowledge support from the Caltech and Jet Propulsion Laboratory President's and Director's Research and Development Fund. A.D.J. acknowledges support from the Sloan Foundation. N.La. acknowledges the support from Larry W. Martin and Joyce B. O'Neill Endowed Fellowship in the College of Science at Oregon State University. Part of this research was carried out at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, under a contract with the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (80NM0018D0004). D.R.L. and M.A.M. are supported by NSF No. 1458952. M.A.M. is supported by NSF No. 2009425. C.M.F.M. was supported in part by the National Science Foundation under grant Nos. NSF PHY-1748958 and AST-2106552. A.Mi. is supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft under Germany's Excellence Strategy—EXC 2121 Quantum Universe—390833306. The Dunlap Institute is funded by an endowment established by the David Dunlap family and the University of Toronto. K.D.O. was supported in part by NSF grant No. 2207267. K.D.O. acknowledges the Tufts University High Performance Compute Cluster (https://it.tufts.edu/high-performance-computing), which was utilized for some of the research reported in this paper. T.T.P. acknowledges support from the Extragalactic Astrophysics Research Group at Eötvös Loránd University, funded by the Eötvös Loránd Research Network (ELKH), which was used during the development of this research. S.M.R. and I.H.S. are CIFAR Fellows. Portions of this work performed at NRL were supported by ONR 6.1 basic research funding. J.D.R. also acknowledges support from start-up funds from Texas Tech University. J.S. is supported by an NSF Astronomy and Astrophysics Postdoctoral Fellowship under award AST-2202388, and acknowledges previous support by the NSF under award 1847938. S.R.T. acknowledges support from an NSF CAREER award No. 2146016. C.U. acknowledges support from BGU (Kreitman fellowship), and the Council for Higher Education and Israel Academy of Sciences and Humanities (Excellence fellowship). C.A.W. acknowledges support from CIERA, the Adler Planetarium, and the Brinson Foundation through a CIERA-Adler postdoctoral fellowship. O.Y. is supported by the National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship under grant No. DGE-2139292. This work was conducted in part using the resources of the Advanced Computing Center for Research and Education (ACCRE) at Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN.

Facilities

Arecibo - Arecibo observatory, GBT - Green Bank Telescope, VLA - Very Large Array

Software References

QuickCW (Bécsy et al. 2023), enterprise (Ellis et al. 2019), enterprise extensions (Taylor et al. 2021), libstempo (Vallisneri 2020), tempo (Nice et al. 2015), tempo2 (Hobbs et al. 2006), PINT (Luo et al. 2019), matplotlib (Hunter 2007), astropy (Price-Whelan et al. 2018; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2013), cosmopy (Kelley 2022), healpy (Zonca et al. 2019), HEALPix (Górski et al.2005)

Contributions

An alphabetical-order author list was used for this paper in recognition of the fact that a large, decade timescale project such as NANOGrav is necessarily the result of the work of many people. All authors contributed to the activities of the NANOGrav collaboration leading to the work presented here, and reviewed the manuscript, text, and figures prior to the paper's submission. Additional specific contributions to this paper are as follows. G.A., A.A., A.M.A., Z.A., P.T.B., P.R.B., H.T.C., K.C., M.E.D., P.B.D., T.D., E.C.F., W.F., E.F., G.E.F., N.G., P.A.G., J.G., D.C.G., J.S.H., R.J.J., M.L.J., D.L.K., M.K., M.T.L., D.R.L., J.L., R.S.L., A.M., M.A.M., N.M., B.W.M., C.N., D.J.N., T.T.P., B.B.P.P., N.S.P., H.A.R., S.M.R., P.S.R., A.S., C.S., B.J.S., I.H.S., K.S., A.S., J.K.S., and H.M.W. developed the 15 yr data set through a combination of observations, arrival time calculations, data checks and refinements, and timing model development and analysis; additional specific contributions to the data set are summarized in NG15 Agazie et al. (2023a). B.B. and N.J.C. coordinated the analysis and paper writing. B.B., N.J.C., and M.C.D. developed the new analysis method, and B.B. and M.C.D. implemented and maintain the QuickCW code used for the analysis. B.B., R.C., M.C.D., K.D.O., P.P., and J.T. performed analysis for the project, including exploratory runs. B.B., S.C., and C.A.W. updated the pulsar distance priors. S.H. performed all re-weighing analysis to account for correlated noise. A.M.A., B.B., D.L.K., and P.M. examined the covariance with the binary model of PSR J1713+0747. B.B. and J.S.H. explored the use of advanced noise models. M.C. and P.P. compared the localization volume of the high-frequency candidate with the NANOGrav galaxy catalog. L.Z.K. developed the method of calculating number density upper limits. J.S.H., A.B., and J.S.K. served as the analysis review team. B.B. produced the figures. B.B., M.C., N.J.C., L.Z.K., and K.D.O. contributed text to the manuscript. P.T.B., M.C., T.D., T.J.W.L., K.D.O., and R.V.H. provided valuable feedback on the manuscript.

Files

Agazie_2023_ApJL_951_L50.pdf

Files (2.2 MB)

Name Size
md5:faff55b60c082a6b22128bc2968925f1
2.2 MB Preview Download

Additional details

Identifiers

ISSN
2041-8213

Funding

National Science Foundation
PHY-1430284
National Science Foundation
PHY-2020265
Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation
National Science Foundation
OISE-2114721
Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council
Canadian Institute for Advanced Research
National Science Foundation
AST-1744119
Ana G. Mendez University System
National Science Foundation
AST-1909933
Research Corporation for Science Advancement
Cottrell Scholar 27553
Science and Technology Facilities Council
ST/W000946/1
Alfred P. Sloan Foundation
National Science Foundation
AST-1815664
Oregon State University
National Science Foundation
AST-2007993
Vanderbilt University
National Science Foundation
Grote Reber Fellowship
National Aeronautics and Space Administration
NASA Hubble Fellowship HST-HF2-51453.001
National Aeronautics and Space Administration
NAS5-26555
University of British Columbia
6456
United States Naval Research Laboratory
S-15633Y
National Science Foundation
AST-2009468
National Aeronautics and Space Administration
80GSFC21M0002
National Science Foundation
PHY-2011772
Simons Foundation
National Science Foundation
NSF Graduate Research Fellowship DGE-1745301
Jet Propulsion Laboratory
President and Director's Research and Development Fund
National Aeronautics and Space Administration
80NM0018D0004
National Science Foundation
OIA-1458952
National Science Foundation
AST-2009425
National Science Foundation
PHY-1748958
National Science Foundation
AST-2106552
Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft
EXC 2121—390833306
University of Toronto
National Science Foundation
PHY-2207267
Eötvös Loránd University
Office of Naval Research
6.1 basic research funding
Texas Tech University
National Science Foundation
NSF Astronomy and Astrophysics Fellowship AST-2202388
National Science Foundation
AST-1847938
National Science Foundation
PHY-2146016
Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
Council for Higher Education
Israel Academy of Sciences and Humanities
Northwestern University
Center for Interdisciplinary Exploration and Research in Astrophysics
Adler Planetarium
Brinson Foundation
National Science Foundation
NSF Graduate Research Fellowship DGE-2139292

Caltech Custom Metadata

Caltech groups
Physics Department